If you’re a history buff, a fan of charming inns, or someone with a taste for truly one-of-a-kind real estate opportunities, this might just be your dream come true. The Historic Buxton Inn, a cornerstone of Granville, Ohio since 1812, is officially on the market, and it’s nothing short of extraordinary. The price tag? $5.85 million for a place that’s been welcoming guests since before Ohio had paved roads.
But before you start imagining candlelit dinners in a former speakeasy or brunch in a sunny garden room, let’s take a stroll through everything that makes the Buxton so special.
History of the Buxton Inn
The Buxton Inn was built in 1812 by Orrin Granger, a pioneer from Granville, Massachusetts, who wanted to create a gathering place for locals and travelers alike. Back then, it was known as “The Tavern,” and while the name was simple, the building itself was anything but.
As the oldest continuously operating inn in Ohio, the Buxton has played host to all kinds of guests over the years. U.S. Presidents like Abraham Lincoln, Benjamin Harrison, and William McKinley stayed here. So did Cameron Diaz, Jennifer Garner, and Yo-Yo Ma. Basically, if these walls could talk, they’d name-drop a lot.
What’s Inside This 212-Year-Old Treasure?
Today, the inn has grown into a pretty incredible destination. There are 25 individually styled guest rooms spread out across five historic buildings, including the Main House, Founders Hall, Warner House, Pearl Street House, and Ty Fy Mam House. Each one blends historic charm with modern comfort. So yes, you can have exposed brick, antique woodwork, and working Wi-Fi.
The property spans over 24,000 square feet and includes all kinds of cool spaces, like a bright atrium-style Garden Room (perfect for showers and luncheons), a cozy lounge with an 1800s mirrored chandelier, and even a wine cellar that used to be a speakeasy during Prohibition. There’s also a stone tavern in the basement where stagecoach drivers used to rest. It’s still got the original fireplace and brick floors, which is honestly kind of wild.
A Resilient Survivor: The 2022 Fire
The Buxton Inn’s long history hasn’t been without a few dramatic plot twists. In October 2022, a fire broke out and damaged part of the inn, mainly in the kitchen area. Firefighters said it was minutes away from being a total loss. Thankfully, they got it under control, and the restoration process kicked off shortly after. The owners have been hard at work bringing it back to life, keeping the original character while updating things that needed some love.
So, What’s the Deal?
The Buxton Inn is currently listed at $5.85 million, and it’s not just the inn that’s included. The sale also comes with four additional buildings that house established local businesses and a private residential unit. So, while you’re running a charming historic inn, you’ll also have dependable income from tenants. There are even over 50 private parking spots, which is basically gold in walkable downtown Granville.
This place is already set up for weddings, retreats, and private events, and with its rich history, it’s an easy sell to anyone looking for a unique experience. Whether you want to keep it going as an inn, turn it into your dream event space, or just live in a literal historic landmark, the options are wide open.
If you’ve ever wanted to own a slice of Ohio history, now might be your moment.
Check out the full LoopNet listing here and get ready to fall in love with this 212-year-old gem.
